← Back to News and Articles

Filling vs Root Canal vs Tooth Extraction: Which Dental Treatment Is Right for Tooth Pain?

February 2026 By Y3 Smiles Dental

Tooth pain can range from mild sensitivity to severe infection. Treatment depends on how deep the damage is and how much healthy tooth remains. A clinical examination is the safest way to decide the right option.

Dental Fillings

Used when decay affects the outer tooth layers.

Pros

  • Preserves natural tooth structure
  • Quick procedure
  • Cost-effective

Cons

  • Not suitable for deep infection
  • Large fillings may need a crown later

Indicative cost: $200 – $350 (up to $550 for complex cases)

Root Canal Treatment

Required when the nerve is infected or damaged.

Pros

  • Saves the natural tooth
  • Eliminates infection
  • Helps prevent jawbone loss

Cons

  • More complex and time-intensive
  • Higher upfront cost

Indicative cost: $1,500 – $3,000

Tooth Extraction

Considered when the tooth cannot be saved.

Pros

  • Immediate pain relief in severe cases
  • May be necessary if infection is extensive

Cons

  • Tooth loss can affect chewing and alignment
  • Replacement is often recommended

Indicative cost: $250 – $600 (surgical extractions may cost more)

Local Service Area

Emergency dental assessments are available for Broadmeadows and surrounding suburbs within 10 km, including Glenroy, Dallas, Meadow Heights, Jacana, Coolaroo, Roxburgh Park, Campbellfield, Westmeadows, Hadfield, and Fawkner.

⚠️ Educational only. All costs are indicative. Final treatment decisions and fees depend on individual assessment, in line with AHPRA advertising guidelines.

Need personalised advice?

This article is educational only. For personalised advice, assessment, and treatment planning, book a consultation with our team in Broadmeadows.